ITA s. 146.2, s. 146 & s. 146.6
TFSA vs. RRSP vs. FHSA Wealth Accumulation Simulator
Model Canadian registered account growth across pre-tax vs. after-tax compounding. Compare tax-deductible RRSP contributions, tax-free TFSA growth, and the dual-advantage First Home Savings Account (FHSA).
2026 TFSA Limit: $7,000 · RRSP Max: $33,810
Rate applied to RRSP & FHSA tax refunds
Expected bracket at withdrawal
Investment horizon: 25 years
Canadian resident buying first qualifying home
OPTIMAL STRATEGY: RRSP FIRST
Because your current marginal tax rate (43.0%) exceeds your expected retirement rate (28.0%), contributing to an RRSP and reinvesting the resulting refund yields a superior after-tax return due to the 15.0% tax arbitrage.
Tax-Free Savings Account
$407,095
100% Tax-Free on withdrawal. No deduction upfront, zero tax liability forever under ITA s. 146.2.
RRSP (Refund Reinvested)WINNER
$514,225
Net After-Tax Cash assuming 28% retirement tax and all annual refunds reinvested.
RRSP (Refund Spent)
$293,108
Net after-tax cash if annual refunds are spent on consumption rather than saved.
Projected Accumulation by Milestone (After-Tax Purchasing Power)
| Year | TFSA (Tax-Free) | RRSP (Reinvested) | RRSP (Refund Spent) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Year 1 | $7,420 | $9,373 | $5,342 |
| Year 5 | $41,827 | $52,834 | $30,116 |
| Year 10 | $97,801 | $123,539 | $70,417 |
| Year 15 | $172,708 | $218,157 | $124,350 |
| Year 20 | $272,949 | $344,778 | $196,523 |
| Year 25 | $407,095 | $514,225 | $293,108 |
Statutory Framework & CRA Rules
- TFSA (ITA s. 146.2): Contributions are made with after-tax earnings. Growth, dividends, interest, and withdrawals are 100% tax-free. Withdrawals are re-added to your contribution room on January 1 of the following calendar year.
- RRSP (ITA s. 146): Contributions generate an immediate tax deduction against your top marginal bracket. Capital compounds tax-sheltered, but all withdrawals are taxed as 100% ordinary income and must convert to a RRIF by December 31 of age 71.
- FHSA (ITA s. 146.6): First-time buyers contribute up to $8,000 annually ($40,000 lifetime limit). Contributions are tax-deductible (like an RRSP) and qualifying home withdrawals are completely tax-free (like a TFSA).